Mark Hamill’s first impression of the Star Wars script was surprising

Color him curious, Luke Skywalker was initially confused.

Star Wars: A New Hope. Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill). Image Credit: StarWars.com
Star Wars: A New Hope. Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill). Image Credit: StarWars.com | starwars.co

It’s nearly impossible for modern audiences to imagine a time when Star Wars was not the cultural phenomenon it is today. However, Mark Hamill, our beloved and iconic Luke Skywalker, recently reflected on his first encounter with George Lucas' script, revealing that even he found it baffling at the start.

On the iHeart podcast Politickin', Hamill candidly shared his initial thoughts and the confusion he felt when reading the audition dialogue, which he described as a "fairy tale pretending to be science fiction." According to Screenrant, Hamill’s first read-through of the script left him perplexed. Lucas was equally vague, urging them to "just do it" and promising they’d talk later — a conversation that, Hamill joked, never actually happened.

"I read the one scene and you couldn't make heads or tails out of it. I said to Harrison [Ford], who I tested with, I said 'You were in American Graffiti. You know, George, is this like a comedy or a send up, like a spoof or... it just it can't be serious, right?' He said, 'Hey, you know whatever, let's just get it done.' There's no help, no help at all. I said to George, 'Is this sort of like a parody? Is it like a send up?'"
Mark Hamill

Hamill’s initial uncertainty is completely believable. At the time, there was nothing quite like Star Wars. While Lucas borrowed heavily from earlier sci-fi franchises like Flash Gordon and Dune, the fusion of those elements into a cohesive and groundbreaking story was unprecedented. From its mythic, epic structure to its distinct world-building, Star Wars seemed both innovative and bizarre, blurring the lines between parody and sincerity.

Star-Wars-A-New-Hope-Obi-Wan-Kenobi-Darth-Vader
Star Wars: A New Hope. Obi-Wan Kenobi lightsaber duels with Darth Vader. Image credit: Star Wars.com | starwars.com

Hamill’s Confidence in Star Wars’ Success

Despite his initial skepticism, Hamill’s outlook on the project shifted as production progressed. Reflecting on later conversations with the production team, he revealed he became convinced the film would resonate with audiences. His optimism came from the simple realization: Star Wars was the kind of story he would have loved to watch himself. Not to mention, with its modest budget by Hollywood standards, the film didn’t need to be a massive blockbuster to succeed financially.

What Hamill didn’t foresee was the unprecedented impact Star Wars would have on cinema, culture, and the science-fiction genre. What began as a seemingly quirky experiment evolved into one of the most influential franchises in entertainment history.

Mark Hamill
Star Wars: The Last Jedi. Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill). | © 2017 Lucasfilm Ltd.

Star Wars’ Enduring Legacy

Hamill’s role as Luke Skywalker would go on to define his career, spanning nearly five decades and crossing media boundaries, from films and TV shows to animation and games. Far from the parody he initially suspected, Star Wars redefined science fiction and fantasy, shattering genre conventions and establishing a new cinematic template. Its legacy lies not just in its box office success but in its enduring cultural influence, inspiring generations of filmmakers, writers, and fans (like all of us!)

This story also raises an intriguing question. What modern project, seemingly unconventional or risky today, could become the Star Wars of the future? As Hamill’s initial reaction reminds us, truly groundbreaking creations often defy expectations, surprising even those directly involved. Now, more than ever, we need bold storytelling to cross new horizons of creativity and create even more lasting memories for generations to come.